Saturday Night Fish Pie

Share this recipe!

So if you ever get down to New Orleans come down to the Saturday night fish pie…Saturday Night Fish Pie - an easy main meal inspired by the musical Five Guys Named Moe

The following post contains affiliate links, which means that at no extra cost to you we can make a tiny bit of money to help support this blog. Thank you!

Saturday Night Fish Fry, by Louis Jordan and Ellis Walsh, was first recorded in 1949, topping the R&B charts and also reaching #21 in the national chart – a rare accomplishment for a “race record” (crossover appeal of such records is one of the major plot lines in Dreamgirls). This song was also described by Chuck Berry as one of the first rock and roll records and had been covered by numerous artists over the year. It was also, of course, included in the Louis Jordan 1990s juke-box musical, Five Guys Named Mole. Sorry, Moe. We’ve mentioned this show once or twice… surely this show must be due a revival? (Hopefully the recent production at the Edinburgh Christmas Festival is the start of this!!) The song’s lyrics provide a great narrative used to great effect on stage:

Now if you’ve ever been down to New Orleans

Then you can understand just what I mean

All through the week it’s quiet as a mouse

But on Saturday night they go from house to house

So, there I was making a fish pie for friends one Saturday evening when Saturday Night Fish Pie/Fry popped into my head… and never knowingly letting a sleeping pun lie unused, I shared it with my co-editors and, after not very much arm-twisting, a blog post was born…

It was rockin’, (Oh yeah-yeah)

It was rockin’, (Having a real good time)

You never seen such scufflin’

And shufflin’ ’til the break of dawn

Or at least 11:30!

This recipe is based on Jamie Oliver’s Fantastic Fish Pie from his second (and, in my opinion, best) book, The Return Of The Naked Chef. It’s a very simple version of fish pie – the sauce is just cream and lemon juice (rather than a fiddly bechamel-based sauce) and the topping is just crushed potatoes (rather than full on piped mash). Despite the simplicity, the flavours are fantastic making the title of the dish very appropriate. I also prefer his use of unsmoked fish – which can of course be substituted in if you disagree!

The recipe isn’t available on-line in any official way (despite originating from a BBC TV series) but is described in detail on the official forum where one assumes its presence must be, at least, tolerated! Saturday Night Fish Pie - an easy main meal inspired by the musical Five Guys Named Moe

It’s a great recipe for adapting: I tend to use a mix of salmon and a white fish (usually cod or haddock, but mackerel on this occasion) which I arrange in a checker board pattern to give each portion a bit of both. I’ve added peas alongside the spinach (which I have often substituted for sautéed leeks) and scattered some prawns/shrimps, again trying to make sure each portion gets at least one (scallops are another good addition). Lastly, I included a stick of celery with the carrots and onions and also half a glass of dry white wine, allowing the alcohol to boil off prior to the addition of the cream. Oh – and I usually double the quantities.

Saturday Night Fish Pie - an easy main meal inspired by the musical Five Guys Named Moe

Before we could even bat an eye

We were right in the middle of a big fish PIE!

Saturday Night Fish Pie - an easy main meal inspired by the musical Five Guys Named Moe

Share this recipe!
Recipe not showing in the right measurements? Check our handy recipe conversion chart!

1 thought on “Saturday Night Fish Pie”

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.